Jan
27
2012

Clear Eyes, Full Eyelashes, Can't Lose

Alright, let's settle this once and for all: what mascara do you use?

I ask because I think I've tried every single one known to man—drugstore and high-end, American and British, lengthening and thickening, small brush and long brush, brown and black and blackest black—and I have yet to find one that I truly like. I've been burned so many times by the promises of marketing (fibres: like a wig for your lashes!) and I'm tired of the disappointment, Internet, just plain tired of it. The one mascara I found and liked—Maybelline Pure Perfection Vibrating Mascara (I know, I know, but it worked a treat)—has since been discontinued because it didn't get approved by the FSA. I've found that I can still buy it on Amazon, but part of me wonders whether the pursuit of perfect lashes is worth the potential risk of a future baby with two heads. (Super bummer if she's a girl; double the mascara to buy.)

My dreams are small, Internet. My wishes are few. I just want my lashes to look longer and I don't want any clumping. Hell, they can make kitty litter that doesn't clump, why can't they do the same for mascara?

So here's what I think we should do. You tell me the mascara you use—I mean, you have to like it, obviously—and I'll make a pie chart of all the results.  (There's just one rule: don't tell me to buy that "classic" pink and green one by Maybelline. I hate it with the passion of a thousand fiery suns.) I'll buy the top three and I'll test them out, with before and afters on the site, and if all goes well, we will crown, by the end of next week, the homecoming queen of mascaras and none of us will ever be disappointed again. Sound like a plan? Oh no, I couldn't possibly accept that Nobel peace prize, sir. I'm just doing my part for humankind.

Recent Posts

Jan
25
2012

Back From Alt

I spent the second half of last week in Salt Lake City, first for the Alt Design Summit—which was wonderful and inspiring and full of people far more fashionably dressed than I will ever be in my life—and then for a quick two-day ski trip, during which I decided that I do not particularly like skiing. Here is the thing about skiing, see: you are cold a lot. You fall down a lot. You wear unflattering clothing that goes swish-swish-swish when you walk.

Continue Reading

Jan
10
2012

I Like Big Books And I Cannot Lie: What I Read in 2011

Sometime around this time last year, I made a committed decision to try and read two books a month. Two books a month? you're thinking. That's child's play! Why, I read two books before I've even had breakfast in the morning, and then I read a third while I'm brushing my teeth. 

(You're not really thinking that, are you? And how many times have you accidentally splattered your toothpaste on the pages? Do you wear a bib when you do this? You're crazy, man.)

Continue Reading

Jan
08
2012

Party Like It's 2012

It is not, perhaps, my most noble goal, but one of the things I've always wanted to do is to throw a New Year's Eve party. I know, I know; some people have long-held dreams of running marathons and writing novels, but for me, it seems,  the pinnacle of achievement is wearing a sparkly dress, hoisting aloft a bacon-wrapped date, and toasting the impending year underneath half a dozen handmade tissue pompoms. 

What, it's not like I'm proud.

Continue Reading

Dec
28
2011

Songs That Drove My Neighbors Crazy in 2011

I am of the school of thought that if a song sounds good played once, it sounds even better played ten times in succession. That makes sense, right? Of course it does. I do this with every single song I decide I've fallen in love with, until it is ingrained indelibly on my brain for the rest of my life, and this particular habit of mine is how I still know most of the lyrics to the entire Jon Bon Jovi canon of 1994 to 1995. Hey, I never said it was a useful habit.

Continue Reading

Dec
26
2011

We Had Ourselves A Merry Little Christmas

My Christmas stocking contained both deodorant and concealer, which leads me to believe that Santa Claus is telling me to take a hint. Then again, my brother Tom received tooth-whitening products from no fewer than two separate family members, one of whom was me. (We don't only give each other personal hygiene items for Christmas, in case you were wondering. Nope, they work quite well for birthdays as well.)

Continue Reading

Random Flashbacks

Dec
28
2011

Songs That Drove My Neighbors Crazy in 2011

I am of the school of thought that if a song sounds good played once, it sounds even better played ten times in succession. That makes sense, right? Of course it does. I do this with every single song I decide I've fallen in love with, until it is ingrained indelibly on my brain for the rest of my life, and this particular habit of mine is how I still know most of the lyrics to the entire Jon Bon Jovi canon of 1994 to 1995. Hey, I never said it was a useful habit.

Continue Reading

Oct
03
2010

It Ain't Pretty But It's Getting There

Have you been wondering how I've been coping without a kitchen sink? Probably not, but I'm going to tell you anyway. I've also been coping without kitchen counters, a real kitchen floor, and---for the last four days---an oven, which is currently sitting three inches away from me in the living room while we lay the tile. On the upside, the refrigerator is there too, and it's been super handy being able to reach it from the couch. Want a cold beer, darling? Let me just lean over to the left a little and open the fridge.

Continue Reading

Feb
19
2007

People Are Strange

1. We live on a fairly busy city street, in an apartment on the first floor, and the bedroom is in the front of the building. As such, we fall asleep to a certain number of fairly expected noises: high heels tapping on the pavement, ambulances whizzing by, pimps shouting at their prostitutes, you know the sort of thing. A few nights ago, however, my slow slouch into sleep was curtailed by a weird, breathy, lilting sound, as if someone was playing a bootleg record of a Jethro Tull concert and kept getting the needle stuck.

Continue Reading

Mar
04
2006

You Don't Need To Clean Your George Foreman Grill, And Other Lies My Brother Told Me

My boyfriend is either gay or a genius. Today he went out to Target OF HIS OWN ACCORD and bought a new vaccuum. It is a very stylish apple green vaccuum that could accurately be described as the poor man's Dyson. His genius lies in the fact that when he turned it on and started hoovering a corner to see how well it worked, I immediately leapt up from the sofa, where I was reading a very important magazine, and followed him around, rubbing my hands together and pleading, "Ooh, ooh, let me have a go! Oh, go on, let me try it! Is it good?

Continue Reading

Recent Comments

Robin
Jan 28, 2012
I really like the Fresh mascaras (Supernova and Firebird). I lean towards Firebird because I don't look for *drama* in a mascara, more volume/feathering. Plus, the tube is so pretty!

Read the Full Discussion >

Starla
Jan 28, 2012
So many comments, about mascara! So many to try! I am going to also recommend Diorshow. Lancome's Hypnose and finally Maybellines Lash Architect. Fortunately I have long, dark lashes so I find any of these work fine.

Read the Full Discussion >

Faith
Jan 28, 2012
I am currently using Holika Holika's Magic Pole mascara (it is a Korean brand and yes, I agree the name sounds funny). This does not clump and it lengthens really well. You get long, defined lashes with this mascara. The secret lies in the wand. At the tip of the wand is a spiky ball thingy that separates your lashes (it is also great for bottom lashes). The mascara is also waterproof and smudge-proof but the best part is, you only need to use warm water to remove it.

Read the Full Discussion >

Isobel_A
Jan 28, 2012
Oh, me too! I have just moved and threw away an entire shoe box full of mascaras I tried and didn't like (from Rimmel to Dior and Chanel). But, I have found it - they perfect, most beautiful one and only! Drumroll please.... Clinique High Impact Curling Mascara It doesn't actually curl (I still have to use curlers, but my eyelashes are so straight it looks like I haven't got any, 'cause you see them edge on) but it's otherwise perfect in every way. Lengthening, holds the curl you put in with the curlers, never EVER smudges, not even when running and comes off in warm water in the shower - so no smearing it all over your face with make-up remover when you're taking it off, either. I am evangelical about it and make everyone I know buy it, so even if it doesn't make it to the top three, try it! Also, I should add that I've no connection to Clinique and in fact don't usually like their products - this is in fact the only product of theirs that I like. I also hate Maybelline mascaras - complete rubbish, they do nothing for me except smudge and clump.

Read the Full Discussion >

Jeannie
Jan 27, 2012
Seriously was just wishing you'd write a post about best mascara. Crazy! I'm so excited to see the results.

Read the Full Discussion >

Amanda
Jan 27, 2012
CoverGirl Lashblast Volume = old favorite L'Oreal False Fiber Lashes = new favorite (gives my short, sparse lashes the Brigitte Bardot effect!)

Read the Full Discussion >

Sarah in LA
Jan 27, 2012
Also, I need to add after reading other reviews, that I was a die-hard Lancome Definicils user until I tried DiorShow. There is no comparison. I kind of want to use regular DiorShow waterproof to see the difference, but I'm on my second tube of DiorShow Iconic and don't want to risk the whole flaking issue.

Read the Full Discussion >

AA
Jan 27, 2012
Diorshow in black

Read the Full Discussion >

Sarah in LA
Jan 27, 2012
OK, I started using Diorshow and LOVED it except for the un-over-lookable fact that it flaked off into my eyes and underneath my eyeballz. No bueno. I tried Diorshow Iconic, and like it so much more. You have to do three coats instead of the two needed with regular Diorshow, but there is no flaking off and i look like i have false eyeleashes. WIN.

Read the Full Discussion >

Cori
Jan 27, 2012
maybelline.volum' express.very black.waterproof.the end!

Read the Full Discussion >

Kate
Jan 27, 2012
Mabelline Full & Soft waterproof in Very Black is my absolute go-to. I love experimenting with mascara but I always have a tube of that for when the others fail me. I've also been really liking Loreal's Voluminous Full Definition a lot recently, with the caveat that you have to get most of it off of the brush before you use it. Like, I blot the brush with a paper towel until it seems dryish and then put it on- a surprising amount of mascara is still there and without the blot step, it gets clumpy...

Read the Full Discussion >

Allie
Jan 27, 2012
Tarte Amazonian Clay Volumizing. It rules. ;)

Read the Full Discussion >

Rachel B
Jan 27, 2012
Mascaras I've loved: Benefit's They're Real Tarte's Lights, camera, lashes! Diorshow Iconic Yep, I'm pretty much a sucker for Sephora and its wares. (Also, its samples... that's how I discovered the first two!)

Read the Full Discussion >

Carrie (in MN)
Jan 27, 2012
Lancome Definicils - it's the only one that doesn't end up smudged under my eyes.

Read the Full Discussion >

Larita
Jan 27, 2012
You're not going to be able to get this easily, but I use the Sei Bella (formerly Nicole Miller) Waterproof Mascara only available from Melaleuca. I've used both black and brown and am happy with either. I'm not much of a makeup wearer, so if I can get it on every time without clumping, you know it's good stuff. And they're not kidding about the waterproof; that stuff does not move until you good and want it to.

Read the Full Discussion >

Lizneust
Jan 27, 2012
Mabelline Define-a-Lash. I don't wear make up a lot, and I like mine to be 1) fool proof and 2) fairly natural looking. This meets those parameters for me. It thickens things up enough that you get the "pow" factor, but I'm not channelling country-western music either. Also, no clumping so far. Good luck in the hunt.

Read the Full Discussion >

Carla
Jan 27, 2012
Another vote for DiorShow. I'm a recent convert after years of drugstore mascara. It is well worth the $$$. My lashes look fabulous even without the use of a lash curler. Love it!

Read the Full Discussion >

Tiera
Jan 27, 2012
Armani mascara it's not cheap but after two months it is still the same consistency as the first day. Therefore it never clumps and is super smooth

Read the Full Discussion >

beth
Jan 27, 2012
Maybelline Volume Express waterproof in blackest black. The classic one in the blue tube, they have some new versions out now. The first couple of uses are no good, it gets to the right consistency after about a week.

Read the Full Discussion >

Sarah
Jan 27, 2012